top of page

Personally Speaking: Lack of lead­er­ship has cre­ated sink­ing feel­ing

2 hours ago
3 min read
My Personally Speaking column in The Sentinel (19 November 2026)

PEOPLE in our part of the world tend to be quite for­giv­ing. Most of us under­stand that things don’t always go as planned, and that pub­lic ser­vices are run by human beings (thank­fully!) who, however well-inten­tioned, are cap­able of get­ting things wrong.


What people are less will­ing to for­give is the fail­ure to respond when those mis­takes hap­pen, and the sense that nobody appears to be in charge and tak­ing own­er­ship.


Unfor­tu­nately, that’s the impres­sion many have been left with fol­low­ing the con­tinu­ing dis­rup­tion due to the sink­hole at Brook Lane.


From the middle of the sum­mer, the sink­hole and sub­sequent road clos­ure have caused dis­rup­tion across New­castle-under-Lyme.


There’s been grid­lock throughout the town, and our excel­lent local busi­nesses have lost cus­tom.


Des­pite the dis­rup­tion, most people would accept that repair­ing the road and filling in the sink­hole was neces­sary.


But then came the news that, whilst attempt­ing to fix the sink­hole, con­crete had been poured into the sewer sys­tem.


Con­crete that has now hardened and needs painstak­ing work to get rid of it. Per­haps this could have been for­giv­able, if after pour­ing the amount required to fill the ini­tial hole was used, inquir­ies were made about what happened and why.


But it appears that more and more con­crete was poured into the hole, and into the sewer net­work, mak­ing an already dif­fi­cult job con­sid­er­ably harder, longer and more com­plic­ated.


Severn Trent is now break­ing up tonnes of hardened con­crete from the sewage infra­struc­ture so that we can re-open the road.


And, because Brook Lane sits over an old canal, spe­cial­ist equip­ment is required to slowly chip away at the con­crete, which may not be removed until well into the new year.


Given the cir­cum­stances, you might expect every effort would be made to min­im­ise fur­ther dis­rup­tion, yet at the same time, res­id­ents found them­selves deal­ing with planned traffic light works on Fri­arswood Road too, one of the main diver­sion routes around the Brook Lane clos­ure.


If there was a good reason for that decision, it wasn’t obvi­ous to the nearby busi­nesses I recently vis­ited to hear about the impact of the dis­rup­tion.


They told me they’d received no com­mu­nic­a­tion from Stafford­shire County Coun­cil, no guid­ance about what sup­port or meas­ures might be avail­able to help mit­ig­ate the severe fin­an­cial dam­age caused by the dis­rup­tion, and not even an offer of someone they could con­tact to dis­cuss their dif­fi­culties.


These are local busi­nesses whose suc­cess and sur­vival depends on foot­fall from cus­tom­ers and con­tract­ors being able to reach them.


Surely, when a major road clos­ure has such an impact on busi­nesses and res­id­ents, the very least they should expect is to be kept informed and given a point of con­tact by Stafford­shire County Coun­cil.


I was told, after writ­ing to Stafford­shire County Coun­cil to raise con­cerns about these road­works being sched­uled, that the works were ‘neces­sary to main­tain the oper­a­tional reli­ab­il­ity of the junc­tion and sup­port future improve­ments in traffic flow through the use of newer sig­nal tech­no­logy’.


Which of course would be fine if we were to com­pletely ignore the cata­strophic effect the works have had on the traffic flow in the short-term. Surely, it is bet­ter to have a func­tion­ing and open junc­tion to handle the diver­sion­ary traffic from the sink­hole’s road­works?


The situ­ation inev­it­ably raises a wider ques­tion about the lead­er­ship and dir­ec­tion at Stafford­shire County Coun­cil.


Since the elec­tions in 2025, there’s been no short­age of polit­ical tur­moil at County Hall.


We’ve seen mul­tiple lead­er­ship changes (cur­rently on our fourth coun­cil leader in 18 months!), with the last leader step­ping back at the end of Octo­ber without any mean­ing­ful explan­a­tion.


Respons­ib­il­it­ies and port­fo­lios have been in con­stant flux, and the chaos and lack of dir­ec­tion from the top has evid­ently spilled into how things are being done.


Every organ­isa­tion leads from the top – the cul­ture, urgency and sense of pur­pose shown in every depart­ment ulti­mately reflects the people in lead­er­ship.


Strong and effect­ive lead­er­ship won’t pre­vent every mis­take, but it should cre­ate a cul­ture where mis­takes like this are less likely to hap­pen – a cul­ture where every avenue is explored, repairs are made prop­erly, and the right pro­cesses are fol­lowed.


And when mis­takes do occur, there must be clear account­ab­il­ity and some com­mon sense.


Res­id­ents deserve bet­ter than a series of mis­haps Benny Hill would be proud of - mixed mes­sages, a lack of co-ordin­a­tion and vir­tu­ally no engage­ment.


We need a county coun­cil that responds to prob­lems with urgency and, yes, com­mon sense.


People deserve a county coun­cil that is cap­able of learn­ing from its mis­takes rather than adding to them. And above all, we deserve a firm hand on the wheel.


If the hand­ling of Brook Lane is what effect­ive lead­er­ship looks like, I think we can be for­given for expect­ing bet­ter.

bottom of page