Personally Speaking: Lack of leadership has created sinking feeling

PEOPLE in our part of the world tend to be quite forgiving. Most of us understand that things don’t always go as planned, and that public services are run by human beings (thankfully!) who, however well-intentioned, are capable of getting things wrong.
What people are less willing to forgive is the failure to respond when those mistakes happen, and the sense that nobody appears to be in charge and taking ownership.
Unfortunately, that’s the impression many have been left with following the continuing disruption due to the sinkhole at Brook Lane.
From the middle of the summer, the sinkhole and subsequent road closure have caused disruption across Newcastle-under-Lyme.
There’s been gridlock throughout the town, and our excellent local businesses have lost custom.
Despite the disruption, most people would accept that repairing the road and filling in the sinkhole was necessary.
But then came the news that, whilst attempting to fix the sinkhole, concrete had been poured into the sewer system.
Concrete that has now hardened and needs painstaking work to get rid of it. Perhaps this could have been forgivable, if after pouring the amount required to fill the initial hole was used, inquiries were made about what happened and why.
But it appears that more and more concrete was poured into the hole, and into the sewer network, making an already difficult job considerably harder, longer and more complicated.
Severn Trent is now breaking up tonnes of hardened concrete from the sewage infrastructure so that we can re-open the road.
And, because Brook Lane sits over an old canal, specialist equipment is required to slowly chip away at the concrete, which may not be removed until well into the new year.
Given the circumstances, you might expect every effort would be made to minimise further disruption, yet at the same time, residents found themselves dealing with planned traffic light works on Friarswood Road too, one of the main diversion routes around the Brook Lane closure.
If there was a good reason for that decision, it wasn’t obvious to the nearby businesses I recently visited to hear about the impact of the disruption.
They told me they’d received no communication from Staffordshire County Council, no guidance about what support or measures might be available to help mitigate the severe financial damage caused by the disruption, and not even an offer of someone they could contact to discuss their difficulties.
These are local businesses whose success and survival depends on footfall from customers and contractors being able to reach them.
Surely, when a major road closure has such an impact on businesses and residents, the very least they should expect is to be kept informed and given a point of contact by Staffordshire County Council.
I was told, after writing to Staffordshire County Council to raise concerns about these roadworks being scheduled, that the works were ‘necessary to maintain the operational reliability of the junction and support future improvements in traffic flow through the use of newer signal technology’.
Which of course would be fine if we were to completely ignore the catastrophic effect the works have had on the traffic flow in the short-term. Surely, it is better to have a functioning and open junction to handle the diversionary traffic from the sinkhole’s roadworks?
The situation inevitably raises a wider question about the leadership and direction at Staffordshire County Council.
Since the elections in 2025, there’s been no shortage of political turmoil at County Hall.
We’ve seen multiple leadership changes (currently on our fourth council leader in 18 months!), with the last leader stepping back at the end of October without any meaningful explanation.
Responsibilities and portfolios have been in constant flux, and the chaos and lack of direction from the top has evidently spilled into how things are being done.
Every organisation leads from the top – the culture, urgency and sense of purpose shown in every department ultimately reflects the people in leadership.
Strong and effective leadership won’t prevent every mistake, but it should create a culture where mistakes like this are less likely to happen – a culture where every avenue is explored, repairs are made properly, and the right processes are followed.
And when mistakes do occur, there must be clear accountability and some common sense.
Residents deserve better than a series of mishaps Benny Hill would be proud of - mixed messages, a lack of co-ordination and virtually no engagement.
We need a county council that responds to problems with urgency and, yes, common sense.
People deserve a county council that is capable of learning from its mistakes rather than adding to them. And above all, we deserve a firm hand on the wheel.
If the handling of Brook Lane is what effective leadership looks like, I think we can be forgiven for expecting better.



